For background on the Historical Food Fortnightly, click here.
The Challenge: “Foreign Foods” July 13 - July 26
Make a dish that reflects the historical idea of “foreign” - either foods with a loose connection to foreign lands, named after faraway places, or attributed to foreigners. Real connections to actual foreign countries not necessary!
I'm in Peru, so anything American is foreign to me right now. But I'm also trying to bake most of my things from the US Civil War timeframe (1860s) and I own a copy of the Frugal American Housewife at home. I'm using my Kindle version here and baking through the book in these challenges so I have some go-to recipes when we return and rejoin reenacting. I also thought this was a good recipe for "foreign" as it references Indians and Native American tribes are sovereign nations.
Indian Pudding (aka "Hasty Pudding as mentioned in Yankee Doodle) was a quick, easy way to make a dessert and bake it for a long time using residual heat from the hearth or stove.
The Recipe: Baked Indian Pudding,
The Frugal Housewife, Lydia Child. (p. 61 in
this edition.)
 |
| The finished product, minus the tasting bite. Not much to look at, huh? That's what the modern recipe pages said, too. Many people serve with whipped cream or ice cream and put it in a mold so it looks nicer. |
How Did You Make It: I followed the directions, purchasing milk from the milk lady a few blocks from our house and scalding the milk (which just means to heat it until it starts to bubble but not boil, then cooling). I put the milk in the baking dish and then added everything else and stirred in the dish. I have used real tablespoons and teaspoons from our silverware for these challenges and for fun compared sizes to my real measuring spoons. A heaping silver table spoon is actually pretty close to my measured tablespoon. I chose to do half ginger and half cinnamon because I love cinnamon but we have tons of powdered ginger.
For those of you who care or want to recreate this: I used 1 quart milk (started with 1 liter and when skimmed it yielded 1 quart). My teacup (which I successfully used in a prior recipe) was about 3/4 cup so I put in 3/4 cup molasses. I took a dinner spoon (large one) and put 7 heaping spoonfuls of corn meal in. When I compared 1 table spoon to a modern official tablespoon measure, they were basically identical. I used a smaller spoon from my regular silverware set and put in about half of one of those (probably close to half a teaspoon) of sea salt because the sea salt here is very salty. I always use one quarter to one half the amount that a recipe calls for. I put in a small mounded (not heaping) tea spoon of ground ginger and one slightly more heaping tea spoon of cinnamon because the recipe overall called for a heaping spoonful of one or the other.
Time to Complete: Shopping took the longest hands-on time as I had to figure out what molasses was called and where I could get it. Success on the fourth store I visited. We don't have a car and I walked to the different stores, but also comboed with other errands. I probably spent 30 minutes just trying to find molasses, 2 hours if you count the walking (most of which I would have done anyway). In terms of making this, it's a very fast, straightforward process with limited hands-on time. This would have been an excellent dessert to whip up quickly with a handful of ingredients and take advantage of the residual heat from the stove or hearth. Hands on time to mix was only about 5-10 minutes. (I suppose that's why they call it Hasty Pudding.) Total baking time: I was aiming for 200 degrees to have a hope of hitting the 3 hours of baking time, but when I came back and checked the oven thermometer said it was 325 so I stopped at 2 hours. Modern recipes did higher heat- about 350 seemed to be the consensus- for 1.5 to 2 hours. I suspect that the oven that Lydia Child was expecting was lower heat and therefore took longer to bake.
Total Cost: about $3.50 USD Breakdown: 2 soles (~$.72 USD) 1 liter of milk (after scalding and skimming, a perfect quart); 14.50 soles (~$5.20) for a container of melaza (molasses); I used about half. 2.90 soles (~$1.04) for a package of cornmeal but I only used 7 tablespoonfuls. Cinnamon, salt and ginger negligible cost.
How Successful Was It?: It depends on your definition of success. I think it baked well and probably tastes like it is supposed to. In terms of if I like it or would want to make it again.....not so very much . I am not a huge molasses fan (true story, my bottle of molasses lasted something like 8 years and I gave it away, mostly full, when we moved to Peru). The whole thing tasted very molasses-y and that's the only sweetener. I think I would probably prefer the more modern recipes which use far less molasses, add some regular sugar and eggs and use a more finely ground cornmeal. I have to figure out what to do with this pan. The most I have eaten is a spoonful and my daughter tried it and was not a fan. It did smell heavenly when baking, though. I expect that the flavor would have been more to the liking of people who lived in the past and weren't in a sugar and processed food saturated diet.
UPDATE: I didn't get to doing anything with this in time and it molded in the fridge. I was going to have my husband use it in a batch of homemade ginger molasses cookies. I would still like to try a recipe with less molasses and more sugar.
How Accurate Is It?: I think it's pretty accurate, the milk is even more accurate than I would have had in the US as we don't buy raw milk there. Obviously, I used my "modern" oven but even that has more in common with a wood fired stove than my US oven as it works off a propane tank and is notoriously uneven at heating. My baking dish is glass and I would have used a metal one (or ideally, a mold) if I had one. (Kit Cusick, I could make this for a Harvest Hop in the future if you share one of your many molds!)
Time to Research: About 5 minutes to find the recipe and about 20 minutes to figure out the backstory on Indian Pudding, what temperature (as that information was left out), what kind of dish, etc. Here are some interesting links I found that might help you if you want to make this.
Modern recipes often included more ingredients than Lydia Child, things like eggs, vanilla, sugar, or maple syrup. I have every expectation that these versions taste good, but they would also be more complicated and expensive than the Frugal Housewife recipe.
 |
| Four stores but I finally found it! Melaza (aka molasses) |
 |
| My journey starts with a trip to the milk lady, a few blocks from our house. |
 |
She comes each morning and sits here for a few hours or until the milk sells out.
I brought our pot to avoid getting the milk in a plastic bag. Not just to avoid the plastic, but I'm always scared I'm going to lose all the milk when trying to get it out of the plastic bag. |
 |
| In she goes! |
 |
After scalding the milk you can see a fat layer on top. Scalding just means
heating the milk until it starts to bubble and turning off the heat before it boils. |
 |
| Adding 7 tablespoonfuls of corn meal (aka polenta) |
 |
| In goes the molasses! |
 |
| I think the author of The American Frugal Housewife would be proud of my scraping job. |
 |
| This took about half of my jar of molasses, which took about 2 hours and 4 different stores to find here in Peru. The main baking supply stores don't carry it. |
 |
| Before going in the oven to bake. It's dark from the molasses and cinnamon. |
 |
| Post oven. |
 |
| Here's a spoonful. It's very molasses flavored. A bit too strong for my tastes. |